Cutting Macros: How to Set Them and When to Drop Calories
A "cut" is not a vibe. It is a defined caloric deficit held long enough to drop fat without eating muscle. The question is not whether to eat less - it is how much less, from where, and for how long before you adjust.
Start from a real maintenance number
Formulas like Mifflin-St Jeor give you an estimate. They are usually off by 150-300 kcal in either direction. Before I set cutting macros for anyone I ask for 10-14 days of honestly tracked intake while the scale is stable. If weight held across two weeks on 2800 kcal, that is maintenance. Not what a calculator said.
The initial deficit
For most lean-ish athletes I set an opening deficit of 15-20% below maintenance. Not 25%. Not 500 kcal arbitrary. On a 2800 kcal maintenance that is 2240-2380 kcal. The reason is simple: a modest deficit held consistently outperforms an aggressive deficit that triggers binges on weekends and gets abandoned by week 6.
Protein first, fat floor, carbs flex
- Protein: 0.9-1.1 g per pound of goal body weight. For a 180 lb athlete aiming to hold 175 lb lean mass, that is 160-195 g.
- Fat: never below 0.3 g per pound. Hormonal health matters more than optimizing a single macro. A 180 lb athlete floors at roughly 55 g fat.
- Carbs: fill the rest of the deficit. Training performance lives here.
When to drop calories again
Not every week. I want to see at least 10 days of data showing a true stall - weight trending flat, waist measurement flat, physique photos unchanged. If any one of the three is moving, do not cut further. Scale alone is misleading because water weight can mask fat loss for 2-3 weeks at a time.
When a real stall is confirmed I drop 100-150 kcal, almost always from carbs, and hold for another 10-14 days. Big drops of 300-500 kcal mid-cut are a last resort and usually come with a step up in cardio instead.
Cardio is a lever, not a punishment
If I can lose fat on diet alone, I prefer to. Cardio is my runway for when diet drops become diminishing. For most clients I start cardio at 3 sessions of 25 minutes incline walking per week and only add volume when needed. Peak prep cardio can hit 5-6 hours a week but that is not where general cutting lives.
Diet breaks and refeeds
For cuts longer than 8 weeks I program a 7-10 day diet break at maintenance roughly halfway through. For prep-level cuts I use 1-2 refeed days per week in the back half - carbs up to maintenance or slightly over, fats low, protein unchanged. These exist to blunt metabolic adaptation and preserve training output, not as "cheat" licenses.
When to stop cutting
If you are not competing, I rarely recommend going below 10-11% body fat for men or 18-20% for women. The returns on health, strength, and life quality are steep below those marks. If you are competing, the cut ends when the stage ends - and the reverse diet starts the next morning.
Need macros dialed in?
My coaching includes real macro programming, not a free template.
See Coaching ->What to do next
- Track 10 days of honest intake at your current weight before changing anything.
- If you need a 2027 show date, start with the 16-week prep timeline.
Related reading
(c) Alex Castro Coach - alexcastroteam.com